This week, I got the answer from someone who knows.
Alyssa Edelman Medina is VP of Support at Fathom, the AI meeting assistant (now part of Superhuman). Her team uses AI on every ticket. Her chatbot can answer most things.
And she just hired four new support agents.
Here is why, in her words, paraphrased for a phone screen.
AI took the easy questions. The “what does this button do” tickets never reach a person anymore. The tickets that do reach a human are harder, more technical, and more nuanced than they were two years ago.
So the job did not disappear. The bar at the door just got higher.
Alyssa’s take on what the human is for: AI follows policy perfectly, every time. A person’s value is noticing when following the policy gives the customer a bad outcome.
She called that not a soft skill, but THE skill.
If you are breaking into support or CS right now, here are the four things she told me to build:
- Technical literacy. Not coding. Reading an API doc without panicking. Knowing what a browser console is. “It’s broken on Safari only” beats “it’s broken.”
- Written reasoning. Taking something messy and making it clear for someone who is stressed.
- Data fluency. “This affects 340 accounts and here’s the revenue” gets you into rooms that “lots of customers are upset” never will.
- Judgment. Knowing when the rule is wrong.
One more thing she said that I cannot stop thinking about.
She recently got around 100 applications where the “describe your ideal team culture” answer used the same four adjectives. Same structure, same words.
Pure AI paste 👀 🤷🏽♀️
It was not that AI was used. It erased the person. She never got to meet them.
Your application is a work sample. Write the one sentence only you could write.
If you know someone who is scared AI is coming for their support or CS job, forward them this. It might change how they apply this week.
The full conversation is on YouTube and Spotify. We also cover what earns an instant no (blaming the customer is one), how her team runs AI QA on 100% of tickets without it feeling like surveillance, and the one question she wants candidates to ask about time off.
Gozde
P.S. If this was forwarded to you, you can get it every week here: https://the-success-path.kit.com